Jay Jay Okocha and 4 other greatest African players who never won CAF's Player of the Year award

Okocha in action for Nigeria | Getty

Jay Jay Okocha and 4 other greatest African players who never won CAF's Player of the Year award

Izuchukwu Akawor • Izuchukwu Akawor • 13:32 - 16.12.2024

The prestigious CAF Awards are back with Nigeria's Ademola Lookman leading the 2024 frontrunners.

The 2024 CAF Awards will be held later on Monday with African football stars led by Nigeria Super Eagles forward Ademola Lookman to be rewarded for their achievements for club and country.

Lookman could be the latest Nigerian to win the award after compatriot Victor Osimhen, who was crowned African King in 2023 after a heroic year with SSC Napoli.

However, with Morocco set to host the CAF Awards and the African football community again, Lookman faces stiff competition from homeboy Achraf Hakimi and three others for the coveted award.

But ahead of the keenly anticipated ceremony, who are the most popular and biggest African footballers who failed to win the Player of the Year award?

Ademola Lookman has had a remarkable 2024with Nigeria and Atalanta.

Here is a list of five (5) of them, let’s take a quick look at them; 

Anthony Yeboah, Ghana

Renowned for his spectacular long-range goals, this African superstar from Ghana kick starts this remarkable list. 

Anthony Yeboah was prolific for his clubs and country.

Yeboah made his name at Leeds United and Eintracht Frankfurt, the Europa League holders, where he twice emerged as top scorer in the Bundesliga - he was that good. 

But for all his excellent performances for club and country, Yeboah was not considered good enough for the award. 

He is Ghana’s third highest goal scorer, with 29 goals in 59 appearances and finished ninth in the FIFA equivalent back in 1993. 

Michael Essien, Ghana

From one Ghanaian to the other, in comes former Chelsea defensive midfield schemer, Michael Essien. 

Michael Essien in full flight for Chelsea.

Essien was an exemplary performer at his clubs Lyon and Chelsea and this led to five nominations for this awards throughout his career. 

However, the closest he came to lifting the coveted crown was finishing third on three of those occasions. 

Mohammed Aboutrika, Egypt

For those who didn’t watch this maestro from the Nile, you need to quickly head to YouTube to get a glimpse of this Egyptian superstar. 

Mohammed Aboutrika made his mark in the continent but CAF failed to read the room when it comes to players based in Africa.

Mohammed Aboutrika remains one of the most talenetd players to come out of Africa and he had fun playing in the continent. 

Known for his ability to control the midfield like a boss, in addition to his impressive creativity and goal, it remains a mystery how Aboutrika was never seen as good enough despite his performances for Al Ahly and Egypt. 

He only managed a second place finish in the 2013 edition won by former Arsenal and Manchester City forward, Emmanuel Adebayor. 

Jay Jay Okocha, Nigeria

I really had to pen down his name, he remains the most popular African to not win this award. 

Perhaps one day the mystery of Jay Jay Okocha not winning this award would be unravelled.

So, not only was he so good they named him twice, Jay Jay was so good that whenever this list is written, his name must be mentioned. 

A member of FIFA’s greatest 100 footballers to ever play the game, an Olympic gold medalists, a world cup dazzlers, former most expensive African player, AFCON top scorer and MVP. 

How Jay Jay retired with only the BBC recognising his crazy ability is a phenomenon deserving of research in an Ivy school. 

Finidi George, Nigeria

Allow me to end this list with another Nigerian and Super Eagles legend, Finidi George. 

This Finidi George special celebration remains why Real Betis fans will never forget him.

Easily one of the best wingers to come out Africa, not just Nigeria during his prime, the current Enyimba coach and assistant in the Super Eagles. 

One of the few Africans to have lifted the UEFA Champions League, when he stood out alongside compatriot, Kanu Nwankwo, for Dutch giants, Ajax Asmterdam. 

Finidi was the toast of European clubs in his prime, with Real Madrid and Barcelona flirting with him. 

In the end, he played for another La Liga side, Real Betis, where he left incredible memories that are still celebrated today in Betis. 

Despite these, the wing wizard was not seen as fit for the CAF award. 

Who else deserved to win this award but never did? Do let me know in the comments section.